My husband and I stumbled upon this slice of heaven last weekend on our trip to Boston. After our early AM flight, we hit opening day @ Fenway then needed a nap afterwards. Starving when I woke up, I found a pizza joint within a few minute walk from our hotel on Newbury, truly not expecting much since they were open so late. My husband and I both agree that this was hands down the best pizza we've had in a very long time, if not ever. We tried the cheese, pepperoni, and buffalo chicken slices. We went the next night, too. We wish we had a place like this near our home in NC. You guys are a true gem. We look forward to coming back and trying more of your menu.

I had the BBQ chicken pizza, and I would definitely recommend it. It was great for a quick and easy lunch. Decently priced too. And the portions are quite generous. The slices are huge and filling.

The food is amazing and the staff there are always friendly and recognize me by name! The chicken is always made fresh and crispy when I order one! And the pizza is cooked well with a crispiness! My go to at least once a week!

Service was quick and pizza was excellent. The slices are big and offer good bang for your buck (5 per slice depending on toppings). I’ve been a few times over the past year and the pizza and service has been consistent. Would recommend.

I lived around the corner for about a year and I LOVE AND MISS THIS PLACE!!! Food is always perfect the owner and his staff are great people . There are 3 must have pizza shops in all of Boston and this is one of them

Excellent service! Hands down, some of the best Pizza I’ve had recently! The freshness of the ingredients and the unique flavors in each bite!! Highly recommend Supreme pizza for food enthusiasts!” The Sicilian slice was absolutely amazing! Perfectly balanced flavors, beautifully presented, and crust is cooked to perfection. It’s a must-try for anyone visiting Supreme pizza

I'll start by saying that I was born and raised in NY, just outside the Bronx. Pizzerias are dime a dozen in metro NY, kinda like Dunks is here. Everyone has their favorite neighborhood pizzaria, and it's more than just a place to get a slice. That being said, good pizza is in the top 3 things I kiss most about NYC since moving to Massachusetts about 10 years ago. I went to college here and I remember being appalled at what was considered "pizza". Bar pizza or "Greek-style" pizza is usually what you find, and honestly, it's an abomination compared to authentic NY pizza. I have been on a 10 year quest for a good NY style slice in Boston, metrowest, SE Mass, and the Cape and Islands. Finally, I was told about Supreme and gave it a try. It's the closest thing I've had to real NY style pizza here in MA. Both the food and the place itself remind me of NY. I saw a lot of bad reviews about the rude staff, mostly from 5 years ago. I didn't find anyone being anywhere even close to rude here, but I'm used to dealing with pushy New Yorkers with a bad attitude, so maybe I'm biased. Definitely give this place a shot if you like NY pizza. If you want frozen bar pizza that just spent 2 minutes in the microwave, go somewhere else. I wish it were closer to where I live, but either way, I know I'll be back. 10/10

Easily the best pizza in the Back Bay! Interior designed for students. The staff is nice and efficient.